Karl-Johan (kjn) wrote,

Some quick thoughts on the Hugo nomination

1. Yes, we saw organised (for very small values of organised) campaigns that managed to put several works that caused controvery (either artistic or political) on the Hugo ballot this year.

2. Organised does not mean vote rigging or cheating. However, any organised group is infinitely more likely to accomplish something than an un-organised group.

3. The Sad Puppy Slate candidates are, based on what little I've read of them (basically the sample chapters of Warbound and A Few Good Men) and about them by the backers, all based on a political aesthetic.

4. From a literary standpoint, the quality of those I've sampled is very low: poor characterisation, railroaded plots, and lots of infodumps doubling as political pamphlets.

5. If those yearning for "the good old days" only can muster this as their flagship works, then they're clearly losing.

6. That said, I think we who wants a diverse fandom and sf must not push back too strongly - that way lies exclusionism, the very thing we want to eliminate. People like Vox Day we will never reach, but we should take care not to create allies for him.

7. Read, or read not, Larry Correia's, Vox Day's, et alis nominated works. But I think one should not put "No award" over any work before one has tried to read it oneself (at least enough to form an informed opinion of one's own on the work). Doing that proves their point.

8. Organise! Or in this case, if you want good Hugo nominated works, then talk about the works you'd like to see nominated, and ask others to nominate what they appreciate. Sf fandom started out with appreciating science fiction as literature, and we should show that.

  • Taco Bell, fold the corners in well

    A fellow filker noted that they worked at Taco Bell and sang work shanties there. Taco Bell and sailors' songs combined into something unholy here,…

  • Glimmering Nymph

    It was a long time since I last wrote here, and even longer since I posted a new filk song. But it's time for Bellman, and in English! It even…

  • Vaccine rollout

    With the new Covid vaccines available in limited numbers, I've been mulling a bit on the principles used for distribution. That health care personnel…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.